The key difference between low-level lasers and LEDs in photobiomodulation (PBM) lies in their dosing and depth of tissue penetration.
LEDs are a great choice because they can be applied directly on the skin. Used in wrap devices, they an treat the target area from all angles, leading to more predictable treatment outcomes. While they do not penetrate as deep as lasers, their penetration is great for the treatment on knees, feet, hands, shoulder & neck.
Low-level lasers (class 3 lasers) offer deeper penetration, which is beneficial when targeting areas beneath layers of fat, such as the abdomen or back. The concentrated and focused light of lasers provides a more consistent dosage. Additionally, lasers tend to be more durable than LEDs, making them a more reliable option for long-term use in PBM treatments. However, laser therapy devices can often only treat a small area, or come in bulky devices (i.e. panels) that do not allow for treatment of the target area from all angles.
Class 4 lasers, also known as high-intensity laser therapy (HILT), primarily works by heating tissues to provide temporary pain relief, not by stimulating tissue healing as PBMT does. Class 4 lasers typically use a 980 nm wavelength, which is strongly absorbed by water molecules. This absorption generates heat, much like the far-infrared lamps used to keep food warm in restaurants. To prevent burns, Class 4 lasers require the device to stay in constant motion and at a distance from the skin, similar to the function of a deep heating pad. In some cases, Class 4 lasers may use red or near-infrared wavelengths, which are also used in PBMT. However, they emit a very wide beam over a large surface area and must be kept at a distance to avoid overheating. As a result, the power and dosage delivered to the skin can match those used in PBMT with Class 3B lasers or LEDs. However, up to 85% of the light is reflected away, meaning only a small portion penetrates the skin and reaches the tissues. Most clinical research on PBMT involves Class 3B lasers or LEDs in direct contact with the skin, which reduces reflection and maximizes light penetration. This technique cannot be achieved with Class 4 lasers due to their high power and associated burn risk, limiting their ability to deliver true photobiomodulation.
Both technologies have their unique strengths, and their application depends on the specific treatment area and therapeutic goals.